Test case ruled out for volcanic ash by Financial Ombudsman

by Katy Murcutt - Paralegal

19 April 2011, filed under Consumer


It has been a year since the total disruption caused by the Icelandic ash cloud, and the Financial Ombudsman Service, also known as FOS has refused to refer a travel insurance dispute to the courts to be used as a test case.

The main issue of the claim was if the delay which had been caused by the ash from the volcano in the April of 2010 was the unfortunate result of bad weather under the travel insurance of a person who is only known in this case as Ms B. If this was true, then Ms B would be entitled to claim on her insurance.

The insurance company has put forward an argument that any poor weather is mostly understood as being atmospheric conditions which relates directly to wind, heat and also water precipitation in its different forms. The idea that the ash was in the atmosphere at that time does not mean it is linked with the weather in any way.

However, Ombudsman Caroline Mitchel reached a provisional conclusion in the December of 2010 that the wind-borne ash constituted as bad weather and it was then that Ms B’s insurance claim was in fact covered by her policy.

The ombudsman was aware of the impact that the decision could have an effect on other cases which were similar, then asked the insurance company to make representations as to whether the above mentioned matter should be decided by the court as a test case.

Under this idea, it ensures the ombudsman has discretion to dismiss certain complaints if it brings to light an important or unusual point of law which has direct consequences and would be better dealt with by a court as a test case.

The insurers have argued that the case had highly significant consequences for itself and for other insurers because of the high volume of cases brought forward on similar wording of “poor weather conditions” and the unexpected coverage given by the media for the ash cloud disaster.

The ombudsman realises that there would be a high level of interest by the public, but was not convinced that the case raised an important or unusual question of law.


 For more news and information on consumer matters, please see our legal news section on the site to keep updated.

Bookmark and Share

Comments to “Test case ruled out for volcanic ash by Financial Ombudsman”


1st May 2012 13:17
cialis says:
Hello!

4th May 2012 7:16
nike free shoes says:
fast shipping, and free shipping. http://www.top-runningshoes.com/ Nike Air Max discounts Originally released in 1990, Nike Air Max 90 Shoes Mens
was known as the Air Max III until 2000,

4th May 2012 14:29
can says:
Hello!

5th May 2012 3:49
generic says:
Hello!

6th May 2012 16:07
viagra says:
Hello!

7th May 2012 18:29
india_viagra says:
Hello!

8th May 2012 7:43
coach outlet says:
Numerous women in the usa and all sorts of a lot more than the planet are each obsessive about coach outlet so no subject what kind of occupation they right now over time have, they'd give anything by any means basically to have their arms around the Coach Handbag.

8th May 2012 7:44
longchamp outlet says:
it is basic to bout it with your physique type.Oversized and abounding longchamp longchamp handbagsss are best for those who are alpine and slim.A babyish longchamp longchamp handbagss can accomplish the accepting accent even taller.Appropriately it is best to baddest a babyish one.

8th May 2012 7:52
ralphlauren polo shirt says:
They accept began summer time advance alms Rob Lauren polo t shirts at everyman abatement cost. You are able to acquisition changed kinds of colors, from sober, adult to stylish, during these t shirts. For that Rob Lauren polo t shirts, you are able to book some own adopted logo design around the shirt to complete you appropriate within the foreground of individuals.

8th May 2012 7:54
burberry outlet says:
Here in the following paragraphs we're explaining various sources to obtain breaking sports news. Though you will find numerous media open to sports enthusiasts. But to gain access to breaking news you will find two most widely used mediums.

8th May 2012 8:00
karen millen sale says:
Karen Millen dresses venue,simultaneously selecting all of the Karen Millen wedding dresses.Karen Millen wedding dresses up somewhat delicately.Take advantage of synthetic fiber camisole by means of jeans jeans as well as set this program upward by means of stilettos.In addition placed on an ideal official coat within it,regarding elegant appear.

8th May 2012 8:06
christian louboutin uk says:
Might anyone will say louboutin’s shoes are as able-bodied top to airing in,but tts absurd to actuate females for whom shoes are basic to their job,like dancers and showgirls,go for Christian louboutin shoes.Christian Louboutin UK News,Christian Louboutin paints Indian red.

8th May 2012 16:06
canadian_viagra says:
Hello!

8th May 2012 16:13
viagra_dosages says:
Hello!

9th May 2012 15:40
Krista James says:
I am glad for this opportunity. I would like share my certification test to all. Thank you for this opportunity that you have given to us.

10th May 2012 13:27
viagra says:
Hello!

11th May 2012 9:28
Coach Factory says:
I am so glad this internet thing works and your article really helped me.Might take you up on that home advice you!At same time,you can visit my website: http://www.coachfactoryonline-us.net

12th May 2012 8:00
DateJust Rolex says:
Please remember that vintage watches have survived for many decades by being treated Romance God created the brand since 1988, the company, registered in 102 countries around the world omega seamaster ladies watches,jewelry brand,merchandise exports to 70 countries, is a specialized manufacturer of watches and jewelry. Romance of God in 1998 to become a global brand,hire famous Swiss designer Wolfgang Jonsson program development of brand identity company logos,uniform color. Romance God omega seamaster quartz watches Korea Co., Ltd. has become the leading companies in the industry, the reputation is well known South Korean brand abroad. God watches Co.Ltd. has always been committed to technological innovation and excellence in quality romantic and fashion capture,fashion jewelry has become a world dedicated to business goals and tireless efforts.

13th May 2012 5:44
delivery says:
Hello!

13th May 2012 8:28
Pharmk483 says:
Hello! caefddd interesting caefddd site! I'm really like it! Very, very caefddd good!

13th May 2012 8:29
Pharmd167 says:
Very nice site! [url=http://opeyixa2.com/rvqvatx/2.html]cheap cialis[/url]

13th May 2012 8:30
Pharme218 says:
Very nice site! cheap cialis http://opeyixa2.com/rvqvatx/4.html

13th May 2012 8:30
Pharma201 says:
Very nice site!

15th May 2012 4:22
Gucci Outlet says:
online sale kinds of gucci bags

15th May 2012 10:17
fast says:
Hello!

15th May 2012 15:39
viagra says:
Hello!

15th May 2012 16:07
fast says:
Hello!

15th May 2012 19:08
viagra says:
Hello!

15th May 2012 21:38
viagra says:
Hello!

16th May 2012 10:24
cheap_viagra says:
Hello!

16th May 2012 15:57
viagra_price says:
Hello!

  • Captcha Image
  • Submit